Shilinyuan New Courtyard-Garden Housing in Suzhou: Residents’ Experiences of the Redevelopment
Set within the theoretical framework of cultural sustainability, this in-depth case study examines the Shilinyuan (meaning “Lion Grove Courtyard-Garden Housing”) built in the old city of Suzhou, China, in 2000. It is a modern interpretation of southern Chinese vernacular houses, with private and semi-public outdoor spaces, and a communal Central Garden. The estate is in proximity to the famous Lion Grove Garden, and in walking distance to the renowned Humble Administrator’s Garden; both of which are UNESCO World Cultural Heritage sites. The Shilinyuan project won the Lu Ban Award, a national award to high-quality construction projects by Chinese Ministry of Housing. Through an onsite survey, in-depth interviews with residents, key planner and architect, and the author’s observations, the study finds that this project is only culturally sustainable to some extent, the private courtyard-gardens are often too small for family activities. The communal Central Garden has somewhat functioned as a social and cultural activity space, and living close to city gardens is a major benefit for residents’ cultural activities. The findings may have implications for courtyard housing redevelopment in China and cohousing development elsewhere. The study finally suggests two new courtyard-garden housing systems that may have wider application.
Zhang D. Courtyard housing and cultural sustainability: theory, practice, and product. 2013/2016, Ashgate/Routledge, Oxfordshire, UK.
Knapp RG. China's houses, homes, and families. In House home family: living and being Chinese. 2005, University of Hawai'i Press, Honolulu, 1-9.
Together Foundation and UNCHS. The protection and upgrading of the ancient city of Suzhou, China, 2002, viewed 15 April 2018, http://www.ucl.ac.uk/dpu-projects/drivers_urb_change/urb_society/pdf_cult_ident/HABITAT_BestPractice_Protection_Suzhou_China.pdf
Zhang D. Courtyard housing in China: Chinese quest for harmony [J]. Journal of Contemporary Urban Affairs, 2017, 1(2): 38-56.
Zhu XD., Huang L., Zhang X. Housing and economic development in Suzhou, China: a new approach to deal with the inseparable issues, 2000, seminal paper from the Joint Center for Housing Studies, Harvard University.
[6] 相土尝水，象天法地。This is translated in the main text: “examined the soil and tasted the water, and mimicked the heaven and followed the earth.”
Suzhou covers an area of 8,488 sqkm with 1,650 sqkm of urban area. Overall, 10 percent is cultivated fields, 30 percent hills, and 42.5 percent waterway (Expatriate Association of Suzhou: Introduction to Suzhou, viewed 31 January 2019, http://www.suzhoueas.org/NaviInfo.asp?Serial=20).
Plum rains (梅雨) are intermittent drizzles in the rainy season in the middle and lower reaches of the Yangzi River (The plum rain season’s super-soggy history by Ke Jiayun, ShanghaiDaily.com, 9 July 2015, viewed 31 January 2019, https://archive.shine.cn/feature/ideal/The-plum-rain-seasons-supersoggyhistory/shdaily.shtml).
China Tourist Cities. Suzhou, 2002, viewed 15 April 2018, http://www.asiaplanet.net/china/suzhou.htm
Xu Y. The Chinese city in space and time: the development of urban form in Suzhou. 2000, University of Hawai’i Press, Honolulu.
Yu S. Suzhou’s old city protection and its historic and cultural values (《苏州古城保护及其历史文化价值》Chinese ed.). 2007, Shanxi People’s Education, China.
History of Chinese Architecture editorial group. History of Chinese architecture. 1986/2009, China Architecture and Building Press, Beijing.
Yuan X, Gong J. The classical gardens of Suzhou: world cultural heritage (《苏州古典园林》translated by Wang H and Hua S). 2004, Jiangsu People’s Publishing House, Nanjing, China.
不出城郭而获山水之怡，身居闹市而有林泉之致。This is translated in the main text: “one can enjoy landscapes without going outside the city, and live in busy streets with the sights of forests and tastes of spring water.”
China Classical Tours. Suzhou travel guides, 2012, viewed 15 April 2018, http://www.china-travel.com/suzhoutravel-guides.html
ChinaTravel.com. Suzhou travel guide, n.d., viewed 15 April 2018, https://www.chinatravel.com/jiangsu/suzhou
Zhou X. Suzhou: the oriental Venice. UNESCO, 1998, 101: 13-14.
Knapp RG. Chinese houses: the architectural heritage of a nation. 2005, Tuttle Publishing, North Clarendon, VT.
Suzhou Housing Management Bureau. Ancient residences in Suzhou (《苏州古民居》). 2004, Tongji University Press, Shanghai, China.
Suzhou Old City Construction Office. Number 20: regarding the application for establishing Tongfangxiang housing regeneration experiment(《关于桐芳巷住宅小区改造试点申请立项的报告》). 1991/1992, Suzhou Urban and Rural Construction Archives.
Suzhou Tongfangyuan Housing Estate Redevelopment Office. Several issues regarding the technical designof Tongfangxiang’s northeast patch (《关于桐芳巷东北片技术设计工作方面应掌握的几个问题》). 1992, Suzhou Urban and Rural Construction Archives.
Suzhou Tongfangyuan Housing Estate Redevelopment Office. Minutes of the meeting regarding Suzhou Tongfangxiang housing experiment in its southwest and northwest patches (《苏州市桐芳巷住宅试点小区西南，西北片规划调整论证会纪要》). 1994, Suzhou Urban and Rural Construction Archives.
Suzhou Tongfangyuan Housing Estate Redevelopment Office. Minutes of the meeting regarding Tongfangxiang housing estate’s landscaping design in its southwest and northwest patches (《桐芳巷住宅小区西南，西北片绿化方案论证会纪要》). 1995, Suzhou Urban and Rural Construction Archives.
Suzhou Urban Planning Committee. Number 27: regarding the approval of Tongfangxiang housing estate regeneration project (《关于桐芳巷住宅小区改造项目任务书的批复》). 1992, Suzhou Urban and Rural Construction Archives.
Suzhou Sujing Real Estate Development Corporation. Regarding the application for establishing the location of Shizilin/Shilinyuan housing regeneration project (《关于申办狮子林/狮林苑小康住宅小区改造项目规划定点的报告》). 1996, Suzhou Urban and Rural Construction Archives.
Suzhou Urban Planning Bureau. Number 242: submission of the validation of Shilinyuan housing estate design proposal (《狮林苑设计方案审定意见书》). 1997, Suzhou Urban and Rural Construction Archives.
Peng Hongnian retired from Suzhou City Planning and Design Institute and was later reemployed by the Publishing Center of Suzhou City Planning Bureau.
Zhang D. Jiaanbieyuan new courtyard-garden housing in Suzhou: residents’ experiences of the redevelopment [J]. Journal of Chinese Architecture and Urbanism, 2019, 1(1): 526.
Zhang D. Juer Hutong new courtyard housing in Beijing: a review from the residents’ perspective [J]. International Journal of Architectural Research, 2016, 10(2): 166-191.
Zhang D. Courtyard houses of Beijing: lessons from the renewal [J]. Traditional Dwellings and Settlements Review, 2015, 27(1): 69-82.
L. Jin, C. Feng, H. Chen, Q. Dong, D. Li, Y. Qian, and Y. Hu. Jiangnan survey report, Beijing, China: Tsinghua University, Institute of Architectural and Urban Studies. The ‘Oriental Spirit’ Research Group, 2004.
Wang JC. House and garden: sanctuary for the body and the mind. In House home family: living and being Chinese. 2005, University of Hawai’i Press, Honolulu, 73-97.
Zhang D. Courtyard housing for health and happiness: architecturalmulticulturalism in North America. 2015/2017, Ashgate/Routledge, Oxfordshire, UK.
Zhang D. Courtyard housing in North America: Chinese design for health and happiness [J]. Urban Design International, 2016, 21(4): 281-297.